THEY CALLED HER A TRAITOR FOR SINGING ABOUT LOVE. Amy Grant released “Baby Baby” — a pop song written for her newborn daughter. It hit number one on the Billboard Hot 100. Radio loved it. America loved it. The Christian music world turned on her overnight. Pastors pulled her albums off church shelves. Christian bookstores in the South quietly removed her posters. Letters poured in — some kind, most cruel. One woman wrote that Amy had “sold her soul for a shiny video.” She was thirty years old, holding a baby, trying to figure out how a love song to her own child had become a scandal. Vince Gill wasn’t her husband yet. He was barely even a close friend. But when a reporter cornered him at an awards show and asked what he thought of “the Amy Grant controversy,” he didn’t hesitate. He said something short. Something sharp. Something that made the room go quiet. Friends who were there still argue about what he really meant that night — whether he was defending an artist he admired, or a woman he’d already started to love without knowing it yet. The exact words he used have been quoted three different ways over the years, and only one version is true… Have you ever watched someone get punished for doing nothing wrong?
They Called Amy Grant a Traitor for Singing About Love When Amy Grant released “Baby Baby” in 1991, the song…